Letter of credit vs documentary collection

A letter of credit gives an exporter an issuing bank’s undertaking to pay when the presentation meets the credit’s requirements. In a standard documentary collection, the banks pass on documents and follow release instructions. The importer still has to pay. Compare the two before you ship.
Create your free account

Key facts

Ask who commits to pay. Under a letter of credit, the issuing bank’s undertaking depends on a complying presentation. In a standard collection, a bank releases documents against payment or the buyer’s acceptance of a draft. That service carries no bank undertaking to pay the exporter.

Compare the payment and release events

  • Sight letter of credit. The buyer arranges for its bank to issue a credit before shipment. Read the credit before dispatch. After shipping, present the documents it requires as the credit requires, within its deadlines and any applicable deadlines under the rules it incorporates. The bank paying under the credit examines the documents for compliance. At sight describes the payment basis under the credit. Allow time for document examination and settlement when planning cash receipts.
  • Documents against payment (D/P). Your bank forwards the documents and instructions to the collecting bank. The collecting bank releases documents against payment under those instructions. If the importer refuses, the collection itself gives you no bank undertaking to pay.
  • Documents against acceptance (D/A). The buyer accepts a time draft and receives the documents under the collection instructions. Record the maturity date and follow up if the buyer fails to pay at maturity.

Work through one shipment

Fictional example. An exporter plans to ship USD 36,000 of machine parts by sea to a new buyer. Under a proposed sight letter of credit subject to UCP 600, the exporter checks that it can obtain the required transport document and invoice and submit them within the credit’s deadlines. A complying presentation can call on the issuing bank’s undertaking even if the buyer later declines to pay its bank. If the presentation has discrepancies, the bank can refuse it. Ask your bank what can be corrected within the deadline and how a waiver would be handled.

Under a proposed D/P collection for the same shipment, the exporter instructs its own bank to forward the agreed transport documents and tell the collecting bank to release them against payment of USD 36,000. If the buyer refuses, the exporter still needs to deal with the goods. It asks the carrier in advance whether the document set controls pickup and asks its bank how refusal is reported. If the buyer instead requests D/A, the exporter checks whether it can carry USD 36,000 after releasing the documents and until the draft matures.

Make the choice before loading the goods

  1. Check the buyer’s payment history and which bank would issue the credit. Ask whether confirmation is available and what it would add if issuing-bank or country risk matters.
  2. Have your bank list the document requirements, deadlines, fees and potential discrepancy charges for each option. Confirm which party bears each charge.
  3. Ask your carrier whether the specific transport documents control delivery. Agree who would handle storage, return or redirection if the buyer declines the documents.
  4. Write the expected payment event and the follow-up date into your receivables forecast.

See how D/P and D/A release documents, compare open account terms, or consult the payment terms guide. Documentary collection is a bank process for trade documents. For a separate cross-border business invoice that is already overdue, you can start a collection case with Debitura.

Read the US International Trade Administration Trade Finance Guide, the ICC UCP 600 rules, articles 1–2, 6–8, 12 and 14–16, and the ICC Uniform Rules for Collections, articles 3–5.