Pay when paid vs pay if paid clauses

A pay when paid clause says the main contractor will pay the subcontractor once it is paid by the owner, which usually only fixes the timing. A pay if paid clause goes further: the subcontractor is paid only if the owner pays, so the subcontractor carries the risk of the owner not paying at all. Whether either clause works depends on the wording and the law that governs the contract.
Create your free account

Key facts

The key question: if the owner never pays, does the subcontractor still get paid? Under a pay when paid clause, usually yes, within a reasonable time. Under an enforceable pay if paid clause, no. In the UK most such conditional clauses in construction contracts are ineffective unless the payer further up the chain is insolvent.

Pay when paid vs pay if paid at a glance

Pay when paidPay if paid
What it controlsWhen the subcontractor is paidWhether the subcontractor is paid
If the owner pays latePayment is delayed, usually only for a reasonable timePayment waits until the owner pays
If the owner never paysThe subcontractor is usually still owed paymentThe subcontractor may never be paid, if the clause is enforceable
Typical wording“within 7 days after Contractor receives payment”“receipt of payment by Contractor is a condition precedent to payment”

Courts read these clauses closely. A clause that says the contractor’s receipt of payment is a “condition precedent” is usually treated as pay if paid. A clause that only names a number of days after the contractor is paid is usually treated as pay when paid.

Where the law limits these clauses

  • United Kingdom. Under section 113 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, a provision making payment under a construction contract conditional on the payer being paid by a third party is ineffective, unless that third party is insolvent.
  • California. In Wm. R. Clarke Corp. v. Safeco Ins. Co. (1997), the California Supreme Court held pay if paid provisions unenforceable as against public policy. Pay when paid wording that only fixes a reasonable time for payment can still be used.
  • New York. The state’s highest court reached the same view on pay if paid in West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna (1995).
  • Elsewhere. Courts in some other US states enforce a clearly worded pay if paid clause, so check the governing law before you sign.

Example: a subcontractor waiting on the owner

A UK steel fabricator completes USD 60,000 of work for a US general contractor on a project in New York. The subcontract says the fabricator will be paid within 10 days after the contractor receives payment from the owner. The owner is 60 days late. The fabricator asks for a written update, records the date it invoiced, and checks which law governs the subcontract. Because the clause only sets timing, it treats the balance as owed after a reasonable time and follows up in writing, keeping its lien and bond deadlines in view.

Before you sign a subcontract

  • Find the payment clause and ask whether it controls timing or creates a condition.
  • Ask for a long-stop date, for example payment within 45 days of your invoice whether or not the contractor has been paid.
  • Note the deadlines for any lien, bond or adjudication rights that protect you.

See also retainage, milestone payment terms and the payment terms guide. If a cross-border business invoice remains overdue, you can open Debitura case intake.